Great Lakes Historical Society collection

 Collection
Identifier: GLMS-0131

Collection Overview

Abstract

Manuscripts, photographs, scrapbooks, and numerous other materials collected by the Great Lakes Historical Society over a seventy-year period.

Dates

  • Creation: 1856-2015

Extent

48.02 Cubic Feet (62 letter manuscript boxes, 2 half-letter manuscript boxes, 17 legal manuscript boxes, 27 card boxes, 18 flat boxes, and 59 volumes)

1 Cubic Feet (9 motion picture film reels)

Creator

Scope and Contents

Over more than seven decades of collecting, the Great Lakes Historical Society amassed a large research collection touching on many Great Lakes subject areas. The collecting scope of the Society extended to all types of materials, including manuscripts, corporate records, photographs, audio/video recordings, subject files, and others. In addition, GLHS retained the records of its own organization, such as minutes, financial reports, committee proceedings, and correspondence. The collection is organized into six series: Proceedings; Specificatons; the Dana T. Bowen collection; Manuscript Materials; Photographs, Artwork, and Scrapbooks; and Audiovisual Materials.

The Proceedings series contains the organizational records of the GLHS. The bulk of the records are minutes and financial reports for the early years of the GLHS in the 1950s-1960s. Some committee files are also present. Most significant in this series are two of the oldest codes of regulations and bylaws for the GLHS

The next series, Specifications, covers 80 years of shipping company proposals for vessel construction, from the CORALIA in 1896 to 149-foot tankers in 1976. It demonstrates the rapid change in size and design for Great Lakes hulls during that period. Notable specs present are the CITY OF DETROIT III, and PERE MARQUETTE 18, 19, and 20. Information present can include dimensions, cargo capacity, engines, crew accomodations, fuel storage, and structural strength requirements.

A noteworthy portion of GLHS holdings is the files of Dana T. (Thomas) Bowen, a researcher, collector, and author. Bowen published several early, popular books on Great Lakes history: Shipwrecks of the Lakes, Memories of the Lakes, and Lore of the Lakes. While some of Bowen's books manuscripts and professional correspondence are present, the bulk of his collection are his photograph and newspaper scrapbooks of Great Lakes vessels. There are 59 in all. The photographs are a mix of those taken by Bowen and those taken by others. There are also several scrapbooks from others, most notably Carl Rydholm, a career sailor with Cleveland-Cliffs who eventually became its fleet superintendent.

Collecting archives relating to the history of the Great Lakes region since the 1940s has resulted in a wide variety of materials being represented, from shipping company correspondence to vessel data. The first set of records in the Manuscript Materials series is a run of travel brochures and timetables for Great Lakes passenger vessels and ferries spanning 1877-1974. Other large sets of records within the Manuscript Materials are lighthouse subject files, which are arranged alphabetically by lake, and "Other Materials." The Other Materials sub-series represents the majority of the records in this series. Materials include, but are not limited to: vessel data, corporate records, fleet lists, company histories, bills of sale, vessel surveys, and many individual and/or unique items. Smaller sub-series document the loss of the CARL D. BRADLEY in 1958, passenger and crew lists, vessel christenings, and sailor certification and licensing. Of particular note is a set of corporate records from the Bradley Transportation Company, covering the mid-1880s to the late 1900s. These records mostly consist of letterpress books, which contain copies of company correspondence during those years. Many of them have suffered past water damage and are fragile. Nitrile gloves should be worn when handling.

The Photographs, Artwork, and Scrapbooks series is a highlight of the collection. A particularly strong collecting area for the Great Lakes Historical Society has been scrapbooks. Volumes from H.C. Inches (a founding member of GLHS), Claude Porter, and Milton Brown are represented. Brown, in particular, created thirteen of the scrapbooks in this series, mainly of late 19th and early 20th century vessels. While many of the photographs contained within are copies (especially from the prominent Great Lakes photographer Louis Pehsa), there is often additional handwritten metadata included above or below them. Several albums of unique images are included, such as the constrution of the Buffalo harbor breakwater in 1897, Captain Murray's album from the GOVERNOR MILLER for 1941, and one depicting vessels being cut in half at AmShip Buffalo in 1917 for transit to the East Coast. The largest part of this series is the GLHS's Main Photograph Collection. This was primary source of images for the organization's publications for decades. For each vessel represented there may be negatives, positive prints, postcards, and/or slides. Most vessels have one folder of images each, thoughmore famous ones, such as the EDMIND FITZGERALD and NORONIC, have multiple.

The Great Lakes Historical Society has created and collected dozens of audio and video recordings, with most dating from the late 1970s to the middle 2000s. The majority cover two subject areas: GLHS Annual Meetings proceedings and keynotes, and sailing aboard Great Lakes vessels. Notable vessels include KINSMAN INDEPENDENT, WILLIAM G. MATHER, JOSEPH H. THOMPSON, BLACK BAY, and HENRY STEINBRENNER. The most significant media in this series is a set of 1" video reels containing some of the original footage taken during the first survey of the wreck of the EDMUND FITZGERALD in May 1976.

This finding aid represents phase one of two of the processing and decription of the GLHS collection. It is based on the original transfer of materials from GLHS to the HCGL in 2017.

Organization History

In 1944, a group of marine history enthusiasts established the Great Lakes Historical Society with a mission of preserving and making known the important history of the Great Lakes. Their preferred method of preserving this history was to create a historical journal, Inland Seas®, which was distributed to members of the new organization as their primary membership benefit; the first issue was published in January 1945.

Since 1944, the organization’s portfolio of activities related to its core mission has grown. Originally housed in the Cleveland Public Library, in 1953, the organization opened a museum in Vermilion, Ohio. The space was known as the Wakefield Museum, and then in 1957 the Great Lakes Historical Society Museum. Also, in 1957, the first curator (and founding member), Clarence S. Metcalf, retired and the burgeoning maritime research library was named in his honor. In 1968 an addition was added to the museum to increase the display area for the growing collection. In Fall 1991, the name of the museum was changed to Inland Seas Maritime Museum.

The core activities of publication, the museum, and the research library sustained the organization without fundamental change for three decades. In the 1990s, the organization followed a strategic plan to hire professional staff to help take the organization from its long-time status as an important, but small, cultural entity to a modern civic asset.

In 2000, after hiring its first full-time executive director, the organization broadened its activities by creating the Peachman Lake Erie Shipwreck Research Center, dedicated to the discovery and preservation of submerged cultural resources. Using volunteer divers, the organization began training workshops to educate recreational divers on the importance of shipwreck discovery and preservation. The program has expanded to include volunteer search and survey on Lake Ontario as well, becoming the Peachman Great Lakes Shipwreck Research Program.

In 2004, the organization determined its current museum was insufficient to meet not only the mission of the organization but the needs of the community. The facility was not ADA accessible and did not have exhibits that allowed museum patrons to explore topics in a real and substantial manner. Between 2004 and 2014, the organization worked toward the creation of a new national museum that would accomplish the above-mentioned items and other institutional objectives. In 2014, the National Museum of the Great Lakes opened its doors to the general public in Toledo, Ohio. This move also allowed the organization to incorporate the iconic COL. JAMES M. SCHOONMAKER museum ship into the visitor experience. The museum tug OHIO was added in 2019. In the last days of 2021, the pilothouse of the ST. MARYS CHALLENGER (a fleet mate to the COL. JAMES M. SCHOONMAKER) was moved to the museum’s grounds. Launched in 1906, the ST. MARYS CHALLENGER is thought to be the longest continuously operated bulk carrier in world history, having retired as a self-propelled freighter in 2014.

While the official name of the organization remains the Great Lakes Historical Society, it is now doing business as National Museum of the Great Lakes, or NMGL. As of June 2025, NMGL expanded by 5,000 square feet, introducing new permanent and temporary exhibits alongside the Great Lakes Community Education Center.

(History provided courtesy of the GLHS)

Conditions Governing Access

The CAC does not have the equipment to access any videotape types except VHS, and cannot access 16mm films.

Conditions Governing Use

Researchers using this collection assume full responsibility for conforming to the laws of libel, privacy, and copyright, and are responsible for securing permissions necessary for publication or reproduction.

Language of Materials

English

Arrangement

The collection is arranged into the following series:

  1. Proceedings, 1952-1969
  2. Specifications, 1896-1976
  3. Dana T. Bowen Collection, 1851-1978
  4. Manuscript Materials, 1844-1989
  5. Photographs, Artwork, and Scrapbooks, 1888-1978
  6. Audiovisual Materials, 1944-2011

Immediate Source of Acquisition

The collection was donated by the Board of Directors of the Great Lakes Historical Society in April 2017.

Processing Information

Initial processing completed by Archivist Bob Graham and student assistant Madeleine Williams. Final processing completed by student assistant Fern Pennington and Archivist Mark Sprang.

Title
Guide to the Great Lakes Historical Society collection
Author
Bob Graham, Mark Sprang, Fern Pennington
Date
2024
Description rules
Describing Archives: A Content Standard
Language of description
English
Script of description
Latin